Your domain registration is pending. Check back in an hour

The Original Josie's Pizza

A family ran and operated pizza shop for over 60 years in the beautiful city of Columbus, Ohio.

Opening at 4:00 PM tomorrow

Call (614) 224-9637Get directionsGet QuoteWhatsApp (614) 224-9637Message (614) 224-9637Contact UsFind TableView MenuMake AppointmentPlace Order

Testimonials

3 months ago

I placed an order on Wednesday for an Italian sub, perfection, I loved it. Fast forward to today and I wanted pizza first thing that came to mind was Josies, so I call and the lady who answered remembered who I was and the day I ordered! In this day and age, where customers are just a dollar sign, it felt great be genuinely acknowledged. I will be a regular because she made me feel like I already was! Great food great vibe great people! I will definitely be returning and will definitely recommend them to anyone who wants a pizza, sub, or wings, and to anyone who wants that nostalgic, "come back again y'all hear?!" Feeling. Kudos You guys kudos.

- Denzel P

a month ago

We were back from Tennessee and of course we came back to josie's pizza. We got our Stromboli and meatball sub. Yummy as usual. Coming back again for our pizza bef6we head on back to Tennessee. We will miss this place most of all. Keep making the best pizza on earth. Your Tennessee friend's.

- Brenda “

8 months ago

The pizza was delicious, but the crust was outstanding! I'm not sure I can describe it properly. It was crisp, like buttery crust, and then immediately tender. I don't know how they do that on a thin crust pizza . . . But they do. I worked at Mount Carmel West for 37 years, so I had Josie's a lot and it was so good then, but, honestly, I feel it's even better now! I love the spot they are in, just down the street from the previous location. There is lots of room for dine in. The staff was so friendly and welcoming!!

- Theresa K

Write a Review Read More

On June 18th, 1935 John Catalfina was born to the parents of Kelly Catalfina and Josie Catalfina. With two older brothers Tony and Phill. And in 1959 Kelly and Josie opened a little pizza shop and bar called. Josie's Pizza (Named after Kelly's wife) and Kelly's bar. (Named after Josie's Husband) Later years, Kelly's bar closed down, and the pizza shop stayed open. Eventually John, Tony and Phill took over for Kelly and Josie so they themselves could retire. Tony and Phill sadly passed in the later years, John and his wife Joyce Catalfina went on to take over and serve Columbus for 62 years! Sadly John passed away in 2008, his wife and John’s son, Jason Catalfina went on to continue John's request. "Keep it going for me." Earlier this year Joyce wished to retire, which Josie's had shut down, but Jason wanted to keep his father and grandfather's dream alive. So after a long 9 Months of being shut down, on September 25th, 2021 The Original Josie’s Pizza had reopened, with now Jason Catalfina as the owner. We hope that our family recipe and love that we put in can be shared with all of Columbus. Without YOU, our customers, we would not be here!

-Love The Catalfina Family